Someone Totaled My Car Can I Sue Them for Compensation?

Colburn Law

Posted by Greg Colburn in Car Accidents on April 11, 2025

If someone totaled my car, can I sue them for compensation? This is a pressing concern for many Washington drivers who find themselves facing unexpected financial burdens due to another person’s reckless or negligent driving. The damage extends beyond just the vehicle—loss of transportation can disrupt daily life, work obligations, and overall well-being.

While insurance may provide coverage, it does not always account for the full extent of losses, leaving many accident victims wondering about their legal rights. In some cases, a lawsuit may be the best path to recovering damages beyond what an insurer is willing to pay. Understanding your options is key to making informed decisions about your case. At Colburn Law – Accident and Injury Lawyers, we are dedicated to helping Washington residents secure the compensation they deserve and guiding them through the legal complexities of car accident claims.

What Are the Legal Requirements for Suing Someone Who Totaled My Car?

To sue someone for totaling your car, you generally need to prove negligence. In Washington, this means demonstrating that the other driver owed you a duty of care, breached that duty, and directly caused your damages.

For example, if the at-fault driver was speeding, driving under the influence, or engaging in reckless behavior, they may be legally responsible for the accident. Distracted driving, such as texting while driving, can also be considered negligent behavior. Additionally, Washington follows a comparative negligence rule, meaning that if you share some fault in the crash, your compensation may be reduced proportionally.

Another critical element is establishing causation. Even if a driver was negligent, you must prove that their actions directly led to your vehicle’s total loss. Evidence such as accident reports, expert testimony, and surveillance footage can help demonstrate liability. Additionally, witness statements and medical records may strengthen your claim if injuries were also involved.

Are There Any Limitations or Restrictions on Suing Someone for Totaling My Car?

Yes, Washington imposes specific limitations on car accident lawsuits. One key factor is the statute of limitations, which generally requires that you file a property damage lawsuit within three years from the date of the accident.

Additionally, Washington’s comparative negligence laws may limit your ability to recover damages if you are found to be more than 50% at fault for the accident. Even if you are less than 50% responsible, the amount you can recover may be reduced based on your level of fault.

If the at-fault driver lacks sufficient insurance, you may need to explore alternative legal options, such as filing a claim under your uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage. Washington also follows a proportional liability system, meaning multiple parties could be responsible for your damages. Gathering strong evidence, such as police reports and witness testimonies, is crucial to proving liability and maximizing your potential compensation.

What Types of Damages Can I Seek in a Lawsuit Against Someone Who Totaled My Car?

Victims of totaled vehicle accidents may seek compensation for both economic and non-economic damages.

• Economic damages: These include the cost of repairing or replacing your vehicle, rental car expenses, towing fees, and any diminished value claims.
• Non-economic damages: If the accident caused physical injury, you may be eligible for pain and suffering compensation, emotional distress damages, or loss of enjoyment of life.

In some cases, punitive damages may be awarded if the at-fault driver engaged in particularly reckless behavior, such as drunk driving.

What Factors Determine Whether or Not I Can Successfully Sue in This Situation?

Several factors influence the success of a lawsuit for a totaled car:

• Clear liability: Establishing fault is essential in any claim. Police reports witness statements, and traffic camera footage provide objective evidence, helping demonstrate who is responsible and strengthening your case against the negligent driver.
• The extent of damages: If the cost to repair or replace your vehicle exceeds what insurance covers, pursuing legal action may be necessary to recover additional compensation, including loss of use and any diminished resale value.
• Defendant’s financial situation: Even if you win a lawsuit, recovering compensation can be difficult if the at-fault driver lacks assets or insurance. In such cases, alternative recovery methods, like garnishments, may be considered.
• Comparative fault: Washington follows a comparative negligence system, meaning if you are partially responsible for the accident, your compensation may be reduced proportionally to your level of fault, which can impact the final settlement amount.

Maximizing Insurance Claims for Totaled Vehicles

Before pursuing legal action, maximize your insurance claim to cover losses.

• Get a fair valuation: Insurance companies often undervalue vehicles to minimize payouts. Obtain independent appraisals, compare multiple valuation sources, and use detailed market research to ensure you receive fair compensation for your totaled vehicle.
• Understand policy limits: Carefully review your auto insurance policy to identify available coverages, including collision, gap insurance, and uninsured motorist protection, ensuring that you leverage every possible source of compensation for your losses.
• Document all losses: Maintain meticulous records of all expenses related to the accident, such as repair estimates, towing fees, storage costs, and rental car expenses, to support your insurance claim and maximize your settlement.
• Negotiate with adjusters: If the initial settlement offer is too low, provide counterarguments using repair quotes, market comparisons, and professional appraisals to push for a higher payout that more accurately reflects your damages.

Lawsuits and Compensation Claims Procedures

Legal Pathways for Vehicle Damage Compensation

If insurance does not cover all your losses, filing a lawsuit may be necessary. This typically involves:

1. Filing a claim in small claims or civil court: If the total damages fall within Washington’s small claims court limit, you may file without an attorney, making the process more cost-effective and efficient. However, if your damages exceed the limit, you must initiate a civil lawsuit, which typically requires legal representation to ensure a strong case.
2. Proving negligence: Successfully proving negligence requires gathering substantial evidence, such as police reports, expert testimony, and eyewitness accounts. Additionally, accident reconstructions and surveillance footage can further support your claim, strengthening your position in court.
3. Negotiating settlements: Many cases are resolved through pre-trial negotiations, where both parties attempt to reach a fair agreement. However, if settlement discussions stall or fail, litigation may be necessary to secure adequate compensation for your damages, legal fees, and other financial losses.

According to Washington law, courts allocate fault among involved parties, impacting the final compensation amount.

Getting Legal Expert Consultation

Navigating a lawsuit after a totaled car accident can be complex, especially when dealing with insurance companies and legal restrictions. Consulting an experienced WA car accident attorney can help you determine the best course of action.

At Colburn Law – Accident and Injury Lawyers, we offer personalized legal guidance to ensure you receive fair compensation for your losses. Contact us today for a consultation and take the first step toward recovering your damages.

Check Out More Helpful Articles

• If You Hit Someone Jaywalking, Who Is at Fault?
• What is the Average Car Accident Settlement Amount?
• What Are the Most Common Internal Injuries From Car Accidents?